Skip Navigation Accessibility Help Default text size Larger text size High contrast page
Go to Met Office homepage
 
 
bullet  Home  bullet  Weather  bullet  World  bullet  Tropical cyclones  bullet  Forecast verification  bullet March 2004

Tropical cyclone activity and forecasts - March 2004

1. Tropical cyclone activity

1.1 Tropical cyclones ending during the month

NWP NEP NAT NI SWI AUS SAT TOTAL
Total number ending during the month 1 0 0 0 3 5 1 10
 
Name Identifier Basin Start Date End Date 1-minute MSW 10-minute MSW
Monty 14S AUS 27 February 02 March 110 95
Evan 15P AUS 01 March 02 March 35 40
Gafilo 16S SWI 02 March 13 March 140 130
Nicky-Helma 17S AUS-SWI 08 March 13 March 70 60
Fay 18S AUS 16 March 28 March 120 110
- 02W NWP 16 March 22 March 45 30
Grace 19P AUS 21 March 23 March 35 50
Oscar-Itseng 20S AUS-SWI 23 March 28 March 110 95
- 21S SWI 23 March 24 March 30 30
- 01T* SAT 24 March 28 March 85 -

* In the absence of any official name or identifier for this TC, the Met Office used the unofficial identifier `01T `. The name `Catarina' was unofficially used by Brazilian meteorologists.

Basin name abbreviations:-
NWP : North-West Pacific (west of 180°E)
NEP : North-East Pacific (east of 180°E)
NAT : North Atlantic
NI : North Indian (west of Malay Peninsula)
SWI : South-West Indian (west of 90°E)
AUS : Australian (east of 90°E)
SAT : South Atlantic
1-minute MSW: Maximum sustained wind (knots) averaged over 1 minute (JTWC Hawaii, NHC Miami, CPHC Hawaii)
10-minute MSW: Maximum sustained wind (knots) averaged over 10 minutes (JMA Japan, Southern Hemisphere RSMCs and TCWCs

Note: Although 1-minute average winds should be stronger than 10-minute average, this may not be the case here since estimates are obtained from different warning centres.

1.2 Tropical cyclones still active at the end of the month

None

2. FORECAST ERROR STATISTICS

The Met Office global Numerical Weather Prediction model produces a 6-day forecast every 12 hours. The performance of the model in forecasting this month's tropical cyclones is assessed below. Mean error statistics for each storm that ended during the month are presented together with a final table of statistics for all storms ending this month. Verification is performed at 24 hour intervals up to forecast time T+120. Some mean error statistics for last year's storms are included for the purposes of a comparison. The present global model has a resolution of 0.83°x 0.55°x 38 levels. This is equivalent to a horizontal resolution of 93km x 62km at the equator.

Click here for details of the TC verification technique and an explanation of error statistics and their sign conventions.

2.1 Individual Tropical Cyclone Summaries

Name: MONTY Identifier: 14S
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (SE Indian)
Start date: 27.02.2004 End date: 02.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 110 knots 10-minute MSW: 95 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 8 6 4 2 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 **** ****
Mean DX 5 -7 23 341 **** ****
Mean DY 12 115 214 567 **** ****
Mean AT 0 18 96 340 **** ****
Mean CT -4 7 81 -253 **** ****
Track skill (%) **** -19 -34 **** **** ****
Mean DPE 33 135 229 664 **** ****
2002-3 DPE * 58 145 243 356 440 507
Intensity skill (%) **** -33 -50 100 **** ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2002-3 season in the AUS basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Forecast errors were below last season's average up to T+48, but above at T+72. This was due to early predictions of landfall and acceleration southwards. There was no skill over CLIPER.

 

Name: EVAN Identifier: 15P
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (Gulf of Carpentaria)
Start date: 01.03.2004 End date: 02.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 35 knots 10-minute MSW: 40 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 1 0 0 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 **** **** **** **** ****
Mean DX 76 **** **** **** **** ****
Mean DY -33 **** **** **** **** ****
Mean DPE 79 **** **** **** **** ****
2002-3 DPE * 58 145 243 356 440 507

* DPE for all storms in the 2002-3 season in the AUS basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Evan only briefly reached tropical storm status and no forecasts were verified.

 

Name: GAFILO Identifier: 16S
Basin: SOUTH-WEST INDIAN
Start date: 02.03.2004 End date: 13.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 140 knots 10-minute MSW: 130 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 16 14 12 10 8 6
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 18 -55 -27 129 126 237
Mean DY 16 -7 -63 -29 107 184
Mean AT -1 29 -2 30 141 309
Mean CT 19 -11 -38 68 63 55
Track skill (%) **** 13 46 45 **** ****
Mean DPE 68 153 210 294 398 445
2002-3 DPE * 57 151 233 306 446 584
Intensity skill (%) **** 43 83 40 -25 33

* DPE for all storms in the 2002-3 season in the SWI basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Gafilo was an intense cyclone which made landfall near the Madagascan town of Antalaha. It then crossed the island twice before dissipating. Forecast errors were near to or below last season's average and skill scores were high. The location of landfall was well predicted in all but one forecast.

 

Name: NICKY-HELMA Identifier: 17S
Basin: SOUTH-WEST INDIAN
Start date: 08.03.2004 End date: 13.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 70 knots 10-minute MSW: 60 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 8 6 4 2 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 **** ****
Mean DX 22 19 30 -106 **** ****
Mean DY 17 108 100 228 **** ****
Mean AT -12 22 40 234 **** ****
Mean CT 19 92 73 213 **** ****
Track skill (%) **** -40 35 22 **** ****
Mean DPE 71 200 200 382 **** ****
2002-3 DPE * 57 151 233 306 446 584
Intensity skill (%) **** 67 0 100 **** ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2002-3 season in the SWI basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Nicky formed in the Australian basin and moved into the South-West Indian basin where it was renamed Helma. For statistical purposes it is considered a South-West Indian basin TC.
Forecast performance was mixed for this TC; relatively poor at T+24, but good at T+48. At T+72 errors were above last season's average, but the skill score was high.

 

Name: FAY Identifier: 18S
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (SE Indian)
Start date: 16.03.2004 End date: 28.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 120 knots 10-minute MSW: 110 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 24 22 20 18 16 14
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX -1 -55 -205 -340 -516 -787
Mean DY -11 82 115 155 172 199
Mean AT -5 28 101 191 155 149
Mean CT -2 7 -65 -166 -286 -490
Track skill (%) **** -4 -7 -18 **** ****
Mean DPE 44 128 269 422 596 846
2002-3 DPE * 58 145 243 356 440 507
Intensity skill (%) **** 36 10 33 13 -29

* DPE for all storms in the 2002-3 season in the AUS basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Whilst forecast errors at T+24 were below last season's average, at longer ranges they were above average. Skill scores were also poor. This was due to the model repeatedly predicting a track parallel to the North-West Australian coast, whereas the TC actually turned southwards and eventually made landfall. Consequently there was a right-of-track bias in forecasts.

 

Name: - Identifier: 02W
Basin: NORTH-WEST PACIFIC
Start date: 16.03.2004 End date: 22.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 45 knots 10-minute MSW: 30 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 8 5 4 2 1 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 0 ****
Mean DX -39 -71 -132 -345 **** ****
Mean DY 3 47 -6 -78 **** ****
Mean AT -30 48 27 -58 **** ****
Mean CT 25 -33 -72 -209 **** ****
Track skill (%) **** 16 48 47 **** ****
Mean DPE 106 134 146 365 **** ****
2003 DPE * 54 150 251 359 498 643
Intensity skill (%) **** 60 33 100 **** ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NWP basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Forecast errors were near to or below last season's average. Skill scores were high and there was a left-of-track bias resulting in some forecasts predicting interaction with The Philippines.

 

Name: GRACE Identifier: 19P
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (SW Pacific)
Start date: 21.03.2004 End date: 23.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 35 knots 10-minute MSW: 50 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 4 2 0 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 **** **** **** ****
Mean DX -16 -10 **** **** **** ****
Mean DY 9 306 **** **** **** ****
Mean AT -33 83 **** **** **** ****
Mean CT -6 -299 **** **** **** ****
Mean DPE 52 311 **** **** **** ****
2002-3 DPE * 58 145 243 356 440 507
Intensity skill (%) **** 0 **** **** **** ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2002-3 season in the AUS basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Grace was fairly short-lived and just two forecasts were verified. Errors were above last season's average.

 

Name: OSCAR-ITSENG Identifier: 20S
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (SE Indian)
Start date: 23.03.2004 End date: 28.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 110 knots 10-minute MSW: 95 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 9 7 5 3 1 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 ****
Mean DX 3 -83 -259 -379 -199 ****
Mean DY 21 86 -16 -119 -78 ****
Mean AT 2 91 164 206 171 ****
Mean CT 11 -15 -158 -272 -120 ****
Track skill (%) **** -21 -26 -25 **** ****
Mean DPE 50 141 272 400 209 ****
2002-3 DPE * 58 145 243 356 440 507
Intensity skill (%) **** -43 -20 -33 -100 ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2002-3 season in the AUS basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Oscar formed in the Australian basin and moved into the South-West Indian basin near the end of its life where it was renamed Itseng. For statistical purposes it is considered as an Australian basin TC.
The model had a right-of-track bias and errors were higher than last season's average at T+48 and T+72. The model did not show skill over CLIPER.

 

Name: - Identifier: 21S
Basin: SOUTH-WEST INDIAN
Start date: 23.03.2004 End date: 24.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 30 knots 10-minute MSW: 30 knots
There are no verification statistics or forecast plot for this tropical cyclone since its winds did not reach tropical storm strength.

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track.

 

Name: - Identifier: 01T
Basin: SOUTH ATLANTIC
Start date: 24.03.2004 End date: 28.03.2004
1-minute MSW: 85 knots 10-minute MSW: -

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 8 6 4 2 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 75 50 **** ****
Mean DX 30 128 225 214 **** ****
Mean DY 26 48 115 56 **** ****
Mean AT -39 -145 -271 -215 **** ****
Mean CT 24 44 50 -46 **** ****
Mean DPE 69 166 280 220 **** ****
2002-3 DPE * 58 148 238 331 443 550
Intensity skill (%) **** -67 -33 100 **** ****

* DPE for all Southern Hemisphere storms in 2002-3 season

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

It is widely agreed that 01T (identifier used by the Met Office) was the first ever recorded hurricane to occur in the South Atlantic. It went by various unofficial names including `Catarina' as used by Brazilian meteorologists.
Met Office forecasts used TC initialisation procedures for most of its lifetime producing fairly accurate analyses and forecasts. Track forecast errors were above last year's southern hemisphere average at T+24 and T+48, but were below at T+72. Forecast tracks were a little slow and some tended to erroneously turn the hurricane southwards.

 

2.2 Summary of all Tropical Cyclones

Mean error statistics for all tropical cyclones (of at least tropical storm strength) which have ended this month are shown below.

Total number of depressions ending this month:- 10
Number of storms used in statistics below:- 9

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 86 68 53 39 26 20
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 98 97 96 100
Mean DX 5 -31 -103 -157 -298 -480
Mean DY 8 70 59 96 141 195
Mean AT -10 21 50 135 151 197
Mean CT 10 0 -39 -95 -162 -326
Track skill (%) **** -3 17 12 **** ****
Mean DPE 59 151 239 389 517 726
2002-3 DPE * 58 148 238 331 443 550
Intensity skill (%) **** 18 18 42 -4 -10

* Best track DPE for all Southern Hemisphere storms in 2002-3 season

Comments:

This month, track forecast errors were close to last season's average at short forecast ranges, but were above average at longer ranges. Small amounts of skill over CLIPER were shown at T+48 and T+72. Overall there was a slight fast bias and a tendency not to recurve soon enough. The intensity tendency skill score for the month was 17%.